Controversy Surrounds Public Health Consultant Hire
A public health consultant's views on exercise and health have sparked controversy, raising questions about the appropriateness of her role. This article will examine the situation and the issues at stake.
Vie Tobar's Appointment in San Francisco
Vie Tobar was hired as a consultant for the San Francisco Department of Public Health eight months ago. This appointment has drawn criticism due to Tobar's seemingly anti-health stance, particularly regarding exercise and weight.
Concerns About Tobar's Views
Tobar, who has written a book titled "You Have the Right to Remain Fat," has expressed views that contradict conventional health advice. Concerns have been raised about a potential conflict of interest, given her role in shaping public health initiatives. Critics argue that someone in a public health position should promote healthy behaviors, even if they don't advocate for extreme fitness regimens.
Criticisms of Tobar's Approach to Health
Tobar's views, as expressed on social media and in public appearances, have been widely criticized. These include:
-
Discouraging exercise: Tobar's views on exercise downplay its importance, even going so far as to discourage its discussion in the workplace.
-
Redefining "movement": She equates basic activities like laughing, breathing, and existing with physical movement, diluting the concept of exercise.
-
Downplaying childhood obesity: On Dr. Phil, Tobar struggled to answer whether she would end childhood obesity if given the chance, suggesting it's a natural part of body diversity.
Weight Bias Training and Workplace Rules
Tobar conducted a weight bias training for government workers, which included the following recommendations:
- Talk less about how you or others eat at work.
- Talk less about your or others' bodies at work.
- Talk less about exercise at work.
Critics argue that these rules are an attempt to normalize unhealthy behaviors and stifle discussions about health and wellness.
The Importance of Exercise
Numerous studies have demonstrated the benefits of exercise for overall health and longevity. Even a small amount of physical activity can significantly reduce the risk of mortality. Experts emphasize that exercise is essential for maintaining physical function and quality of life, particularly in older age.
Rejecting the Notion of Exercise as Solely Weight Loss
The common misconception that exercise is solely for weight loss is harmful. Society needs to do a better job emphasizing that exercise is a life-long endeavor for optimal physical and mental well-being. Exercise contributes to mood, energy, memory, learning and overall brain function.
Tobar's Defense and the Body Positivity Movement
Tobar's perspective aligns with the body positivity and health at every size movements. However, critics argue that these movements can promote unhealthy lifestyles and normalize obesity. Concerns are also raised about the potential influence of these ideologies on public health policy.
Questioning the Rationale for the Hire
The article raises questions about why San Francisco hired someone with Tobar's views for a public health role. The author speculates on motives and potential unintended consequences of such an appointment.
Childhood Obesity Concerns
The article stresses that childhood obesity is a real and growing problem. It states children are consuming junk food and spend too much time in front of screens, leading to underdeveloped muscles and other health problems. The fact that Tobar would not end childhood obesity if given the choice is terrifying to the author.
{# 
{# 
{# 
{# 
{#