The Looming AI-Driven Economic Paradox
The increasing capabilities of AI are raising critical questions about the future of employment and the consumer economy. If AI eliminates a significant portion of jobs, who will be able to afford the products and services that companies are trying to sell? This creates a potential corporate suicide pact, where automation undermines the very customer base that businesses rely on. This article explores this paradox and its potential consequences.
The Deflationary Death Spiral
Basic Economics and Consumer Spending
Consumer spending is a major driver of the economy, accounting for roughly 70% in the U.S. Job losses lead to decreased consumer spending, which in turn results in reduced company revenue and further layoffs. This creates a deflationary death spiral, a dangerous cycle of economic decline.
AI's Impact on Employment
Studies predict that AI could displace millions of workers. MIT and Boston University research suggests 2 million manufacturing workers in the US alone will be displaced by the end of 2024, while McKinsey estimates that between 400 and 800 million individuals globally could be displaced by automation by 2030. Furthermore, Goldman Sachs research indicates that 300 million jobs in the U.S. and Europe could be lost or degraded due to AI adoption.
The 2008 Recession as a Warning
During the 2007-2009 recession, a consumer spending cut of just $200 billion triggered a massive economic collapse. If AI eliminates hundreds of millions of jobs globally, it raises the question of where companies expect their revenue to come from. Will robots start buying products and services?
Corporate Actions Accelerating the Crisis
Several major tech companies are taking actions that exacerbate this potential economic crisis:
-
Meta: Instructed managers to place 20% of employees in the "below expectations" performance category, up from 15% last year, leading to significant layoffs (potentially 15,000 employees).
-
Microsoft: Cut 6,000 roles to improve the ratio of coders to non-coders.
-
Google: Reduced management by 10% in an efficiency drive.
These companies are racing to automate and cut costs, potentially undermining their future customer base.
Google's Elimination of Search
Google is replacing traditional search with AI agents that browse the web and summarize content for users. This could decimate publishers, content creators, and websites that rely on human visitors. They are attempting to capture all human attention through AI intermediaries.
Robots with Credit Cards
Payment companies like Visa and MasterCard are developing tokenized payment systems for AI agents, essentially giving robots their own credit cards with spending limits. This highlights a focus on automating the entire shopping experience, potentially leaving humans as passive economic participants.
The Disconnect from Economic Reality
Massive AI Investments in the Middle East
OpenAI is partnering on large-scale AI infrastructure projects in the Middle East, including data centers in the UAE and Saudi Arabia's $100 billion AI initiative, Project Transcendence. These investments are occurring while companies are simultaneously eliminating the purchasing power of workers in countries where they expect to sell their products.
Treating AI Like Standard Oil
Tech companies are treating AI like Standard Oil treated petroleum, pursuing vertical integration from energy production to distribution channels. They are building infrastructure for an AI-driven economy, potentially without considering who will be able to afford their products.
Historical Parallels and the Future
Economic Doom Prophecy
The potential for a significant decline in consumer spending is reminiscent of past economic crises. In 2020, Americans spent $500 billion less on consumption than the previous year, and it took until 2022 to recover to 2019 levels. Similarly, the 2008-2009 financial crisis saw a severe decline in consumer spending.
The Difference Between Then and Now
The 2008 recession was cyclical, with the expectation that jobs would eventually return. The AI revolution is structural, with jobs being permanently automated away.
Possible Outcomes
Three possible outcomes are presented, none of which are particularly positive:
- Feudal Tech Lords: A small elite of AI owners control the majority of wealth and power, while the rest of the population relies on basic income and minimal consumption.
- Deflationary Death Spiral: Mass unemployment leads to economic collapse, bank failures, and a return to a barter economy.
- Corporate UBI Subsidy: Tech companies push for Universal Basic Income (UBI) to maintain consumer spending and their own wealth extraction system, but it creates permanent economic dependency.
Even in the best-case UBI scenario, the population becomes dependent on government subsistence and loses economic independence.
Surviving the Transformation: An Action Plan
Become an AI Puppet Master (Temporarily)
While not a long-term solution, mastering AI tools can provide temporary job security and income.
Think Like a Prepper
Diversify skills beyond tech, learning practical skills like growing food, fixing things, and providing services that will always be needed.
Build Real Relationships
Develop strong connections within your community to create networks of mutual aid for increased independence.
Adapt Wealth-Building Strategies
Traditional wealth-building strategies may become obsolete. Focus on positioning yourself as essential to those who control the system.
Reduce Economic Vulnerability
Minimize debt, build emergency funds, and consider alternative store of value assets.
Stay Adaptable
Be prepared to pivot quickly as economic conditions change, recognizing that stable careers are becoming less common.
Timing is Everything
While the exact timing of this economic transformation is uncertain, the warning signs are already appearing. The key is to recognize the change that is coming and position yourself accordingly. Develop multiple income streams, build real-world skills, and strengthen local networks to become economically anti-fragile.